Inn Consultants and Brokers Since 1993

Cooperstown Inn

Cooperstown New York Boutique Hotel for Sale

A top destination location equals strong year-round business. This Cooperstown New York boutique hotel for sale is just that. The property features eighteen guest accommodations and a very viable bottom line.

Cooperstown New York Boutique Hotel for Sale

Profitable boutique Inn two blocks from the National Baseball Hall of Fame!

Sold by The B&B Team August 2022! We are very pleased to offer a top-tier Cooperstown New York boutique hotel for Sale. Almost everyone knows that Cooperstown, New York, is the home of the National Baseball Hall of Fame, a two-block walk from the Inn.  Many also know that Cooperstown is home to the world-renowned Glimmerglass Opera Company.  Among other attractions are a first-class art museum (Fenimore Art Museum), an excellent Farmers’ Museum, and a Chamber Music Festival.  The main street of the village is replete with excellent eateries and shops, many of which are themed to baseball. A lifestyle bonus for owners is the state-of-the-art Clark Sports Center, a mere mile from the Inn. Brewery Ommegang, a nationally celebrated Belgian Brewery, partners with the Inn for several special weekend packages.  The result of the very favorable location is a sensational occupancy rate, and a higher than average daily room rate.

Built as a hotel in 1874, the Second Empire architectural style building was designed by architect Henry J. Hardenbergh, most noted for his designs of the Dakota Apartments and The Plaza Hotel in New York City.

The hotel has picturesque curb appeal in a neighborhood lined with other historic homes of Cooperstown. The property offers the ideal park and walk proximity to the charming village with its restaurants and shops, anchored by the National Baseball Hall of Fame.

A top destination location equals strong year-round business at this very viable Cooperstown hospitality property.

The property features eighteen guest accommodations. One two-bedroom, two-bath luxury suite, and one two-room premium suite are included in the mix of rooms. The first floor features two classic parlors, one with a fireplace, and two dining rooms, one with a fireplace. Beautiful original woodwork, high ceilings and fireplaces add warmth to these areas. Current innkeepers offer a buffet-style breakfast prepared in the kitchen adjacent to the dining room. The front hall leads to the convenient reception area.

Most of the guest rooms are located on the second and third floors, but there is a fully handicap-accessible room available on the first floor with a ramp at the rear of the Inn. Off-street parking is available in the rear of the building with a conveniently located back entrance. Of note, the Inn has the only Tesla/EV charging station within 30 miles. The expansive front porch with plenty of rockers is a perfect spot to sit and watch the world go by after a day of exploring.

In addition to the National Baseball Hall of Fame, which is one of the biggest draws to Cooperstown, the area holds other enticing attractions.

The Upper Susquehanna River Region is a wonderful area to explore with leisurely auto and cycling trips.

The Cooperstown New York hotel for sale features a Bicycle Club House where guests can securely store their bikes. The scenic roads, byways and hilly terrain surrounding the property provide some of the best cycling in the Northeast. For a short video, please click here.

The hotel has created one of the best behind-the-scenes tours of The Baseball Hall of Fame. Clever packaging partnering with the museum as well as the widely known Brewery Ommegang has created guest loyalty and profitability adding to the bottom line! The inn is a member of Select Registry, a marketing organization featuring distinctive Inns across the country, and is also listed on the National Register of Historic Places.

There are two adjacent properties that could serve as owner’s or manager’s quarters and/or additional lodging units. Seriously interested buyers are encouraged to contact us for details on these enhancements and to discuss their interest generally in the property.

This high-quality Cooperstown New York boutique hotel for sale was sold by The B&B Team, Inn Partners LLC on August 22, 2022. New York state broker of record was Stack-Page Properties.

For details, please contact Eben Viens at 877-957-2360.

Business Type

  • Financially Viable


  • More than $3 Million


  • Mid Atlantic


  • 11 - 20 Rooms

Property Type

  • Bed & Breakfast
  • Boutique Hotel


  • Select Registry
  • Asking Price: $
  • Property Type: Bed & Breakfast, Boutique Hotel
  • Business Type: Financially Viable
  • Region: Mid Atlantic
  • Status: Sold
  • Rooms: 18
  • Features: Select Registry
  • Bathrooms: 19
  • Contact: Eben Viens
  • Phone: 802-257-2360
  • Email:
  • Printer Friendly Flyer
  • Association of Lodging Professionals Logo
  • Stay Local
facebook twitter pinterest mail rss